Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher rate the Premier League's biggest summer transfers

Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher have cast their eye over the summer's major dealings with the ex-Liverpool man not convinced by Chelsea's decision to land Alejandro Garnacho.

They signed the Argentine from Manchester United late in the window but Carragher is not sure the winger, whose attitude was called into question, will be the right fit. He is however impressed by the start made by Joao Pedro, who has already found the net for the Blues.

Carragher equally still needs to be convinced on Liverpool new boy Florian Wirtz, despite him joining for a then British-record £116m. The German playmaker arrives with a huge reputation but the Sky Sports pundit said: "He's obviously got quality".

Both men were aligned in their belief that Jack Grealish's loan move to Everton will be a big success. The playmaker has already laid on a number of goals as he looks to revive his career with the Toffees after a difficult stint at Manchester City.

Arsenal signing Eberechi Eze, Manchester City new boy Tijjani Reijnders and Manchester United duo Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo also got the thumbs up despite only being at their new clubs for a matter of games.

READ MORE: Liverpool 'behaving like Sir Alex Ferguson's Man Utd' with bold new transfer strategy

READ MORE: Emi Martinez may have to alter transfer stance after Man Utd snub to avoid embarrassing saga

Benjamin Sesko though still needs to prove he can cut it, but he's largely been used from the bench since his £74million move from RB Leipzig, albeit he's yet to score. "It's not going to be easy coming into Old Trafford," said Carragher. "You know he's not been given a run of games yet."

Keane meanwhile cast doubt over Tottenham's business, particularly the decision to sign Mohamed Kudus from West Ham. The north Londoners spent £55m to land the winger, but the Irishman believes he failed to produce enough last year and believes he may fall short of the mark.

He said: "Not convinced, I have to say, but it would be nice if he surprises me." Carragher echoed that sentiment as he added: "He was hit and miss with West Ham wasn't he? Had a really good first season, then not so great, and he's been a little bit like that this season."

Carragher and Keane's verdict

Noni Madueke to Arsenal

Keane - too early to tell

Carragher - too early to tell

Viktor Gyokeres to Arsenal

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Eberechi Eze to Arsenal

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Joao Pedro to Chelsea

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Alejandro Garnacho to Chelsea

Keane - too early to tell

Carragher - miss

Jack Grealish to Everton

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Florian Wirtz to Liverpool

Keane - hit

Carragher - too early to tell

Hugo Ekitike to Liverpool

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Tijjani Reijnders to Man City

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Matheus Cunha to Man Utd

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Bryan Mbeumo to Man Utd

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Benjamin Sesko to Man Utd

Keane - too early to tell

Carragher - too early to tell

Mohamed Kudus to Spurs

Keane - miss

Carragher - miss

Xavi Simons to Spurs

Keane - hit

Carragher - hit

Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.